Skip to content

Choose your country for free shipping progress.

Sharny & Julius Protein

Should You Mix Protein Powder With Milk or Water?

You can mix protein powder with milk, water or plant milk. Water keeps the shake light and adds nothing. Milk makes it creamier and more filling, with extra calories and some protein. Plant milk is creamy with no dairy. Pick water for a light shake and milk for taste and fuel.

By Sharny & Julius Kieser · Co-founders of S&J · Parents of 6

Key takeaways

  • You can mix protein powder with milk, water or plant milk.
  • Water is lightest and adds no calories.
  • Milk makes it creamier and more filling.
Show 3 more
  • Dairy doesn't suit you? Use water or plant milk.
  • Start with one scoop in 250 to 300ml of liquid.
  • Pick a powder you enjoy with just water.

It's 6:40am. Lunchboxes on the bench, a scoop of protein in your shaker. You open the fridge, look at the milk, then look back at the tap. Which one are you supposed to use?

It's one of the most common protein powder questions, and the answer depends on your goal. Here's what milk and water each do, and how to pick the right one in five seconds.

Can you mix protein powder with milk?

Yes. You can mix protein powder with milk, water or plant milk. Most powders are made to work with all three. Our Nourish directions say one scoop with 250 to 300ml (about 8 to 10 oz) of water, milk or plant milk.

  • Water: the lightest, simplest shake
  • Milk: creamier, with extra calories and protein
  • Plant milk: creamy without dairy

Is protein powder better with milk or water?

Protein powder isn't better with milk or water. It's better with whichever fits your goal. Water keeps the shake light and adds nothing. Milk adds calories, some protein and a creamier taste. Check the nutrition label on your carton for the exact numbers.

Mixer Best for
Water Counting calories, a quick shake on the go
Dairy milk A creamier taste and a more filling shake
Plant milk Creamy, with no dairy
Half and half A middle ground on taste and calories

Why do most people add milk?

Most people add milk to cover up the taste. Plenty of protein powders taste chalky or gritty with water. Milk hides it. We made Nourish so you don't have to.

"Most plant proteins need milk or a banana to be palatable. Nourish tastes creamy and smooth with just water." From our Nourish FAQ

Step 1 of 5

Step 1: Pick water for a light, simple shake

Water is the easy choice when you're counting calories or drinking it on the go. It doesn't need a fridge, so you can keep powder in a shaker and add water at the gym, office or school gate.

  • Use cold water for a better taste.
  • Add ice if you have a blender.
  • Shake for 20 seconds so there are no clumps.

Step 2 of 5

Step 2: Pick milk for a creamier, more filling shake

Milk makes a shake taste more like a milkshake, and it adds calories and protein. That suits you if the shake is replacing a snack or you're trying to eat more. Skim milk adds less than whole milk.

Step 3 of 5

Step 3: Pick plant milk if dairy doesn't suit you

If dairy leaves you uncomfortable, mixing a dairy-free powder with cow's milk puts the dairy straight back in. Use water, or an almond, oat or soy milk you like. Read the carton, because some plant milks have added sugar.

Step 4 of 5

Step 4: Get the ratio right

Too little liquid makes a thick, gritty shake. Too much makes it watery. Start with one scoop in 250 to 300ml (about 8 to 10 oz), then adjust next time.

  • Too thick? Add a splash more liquid.
  • Too thin? Use a little less next time.
  • Liquid first, then powder, then shake.

No blender? Read how to make a protein shake without a blender.

Step 5 of 5

Step 5: Use a powder that tastes good with just water

The easiest way to skip the milk question is a powder you enjoy with water. That's why we drink Nourish. Each serve has 20g of pea protein isolate, zero sugar and no artificial sweeteners, and it's dairy free.

Nourish plant protein tubs, a protein powder you can mix with milk or water

What customers say about Nourish

"Amazing taste and texture even though it's only mixed with water!!!"

Jennifer, Nourish customer review

"My go-to for my daily protein intake as well as my family's. I love it pure or mixed with Kid's healthy chocolate and some chai spices."

Nadine, Nourish customer review

Results vary.

What's in Nourish?

Nourish is a plant protein made from pea protein isolate. Here are the basics from the product page.

Per serve Nourish
Protein 20g, from pea protein isolate
Sugar Zero
Dairy, lactose, soy None
Artificial sweeteners None
Nourish plant protein in Vanilla and Salted Caramel

Sharny & Julius · Protein

A shake that tastes good with just water

See what’s in Nourish™, how to take it and what customers say.

Try Nourish

$47

How much does Nourish cost?

Nourish is $47 a tub of 30 serves, about $1.57 a shake. You can subscribe and save, and pause, skip or cancel any time.

  • Flavors include Vanilla and Salted Caramel.
  • It's for adults who want a simple, dairy-free shake.
  • It doesn't replace real meals every day.

Try Nourish

When should you check with a doctor?

Check with your doctor before using protein powder if you're pregnant or breastfeeding, take medication, or have a medical condition. Ask your pediatrician before giving any supplement to a child.

Milk, water or both

There's no wrong answer, only the one that fits your morning. Water for light and quick, milk for creamy and filling, plant milk for no dairy. Tomorrow at 6:40, you'll know which tap to turn.

We're Sharny and Julius Kieser, parents of 6. Over 1M people follow us on Facebook, 1.3M on Instagram and about 350k on TikTok (@themarriagereset).

More about us. Also read how to use protein powder, protein shakes on an empty stomach and protein powder without artificial sweeteners.

Updated Nov 17, 2026 · By Julius Kieser · Co-founder of S&J

*These statements have not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration. This product is not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease.

Protein powder with milk or water FAQ

Can you mix protein powder with milk?

Yes. Most protein powders work with milk, water or plant milk. Our Nourish directions say one scoop with 250 to 300ml (about 8 to 10 oz) of water, milk or plant milk.

Is it better to mix protein powder with milk or water?

Neither is better for everyone. Water keeps the shake light and lower in calories. Milk makes it creamier and more filling, with extra calories and some protein.

Can you mix protein powder with milk instead of water?

Yes. Swap it one for one. Expect a thicker, creamier shake with more calories. If dairy doesn't sit well with you, try plant milk instead.

Does Nourish taste good with just water?

Yes. Our FAQ says Nourish tastes creamy and smooth with just water. Many people still like it with milk or blended into a smoothie on busy mornings.

How much liquid do I mix with one scoop?

Start with 250 to 300ml (about 8 to 10 oz) per scoop. Add a splash more if it's too thick, or use a little less next time if it's too thin.